Bloody Scotland McIlvanney Prize 2026 Shortlist

BLOODY SCOTLAND REVEALS THE FINALISTS FOR THE McILVANNEY PRIZE 2026
sponsored by the Glencairn Glass
Winner to be presented at 5pm on Friday 18 September 2026

This year the McIlvanney Prize is being judged by well-known broadcasters, Nicola Meighan and Sally Magnusson and crime reviewer, Gordon McGhie. Today they reveal the books they have selected as finalists and why:



Tariq Ashkanani - The Hollow Boys (Viper)

‘A powerful evocation of small town America and a deftly handled plot with an impossibly chilling mystery at its heart.’

Gavin Bell - 138 Main Street (S&S)

‘A genuinely unputdownable serial killer novel. We loved the originality and the sheer scale (both geographical and imaginative) of this thriller.’

Frances Crawford - A Bad, Bad Place (Transworld)

‘A bold, vital and original voice in Scottish crime writing. Full of wit and humanity, the characters stay with you long after you put the novel down.’

Philip Miller - The Diary of Lies (Polygon)

‘Absolutely beautiful prose evoking the Fife Coast and Edinburgh under snow. A truly exquisite sense of pace and a strong female lead character.’

Zoë Rankin - The Vanishing Place (Viper)

‘A gripping story about a forgotten family, alone and vulnerable in the New Zealand wilderness. We loved the strong characterisation in this compelling debut.’

Tariq Ashkanani was the winner of the McIlvanney Prize 2025 and also won the Bloody Scotland Debut Prize in 2022. He is one of the most established names on the list, which includes two debut authors – Frances Crawford and Zoë Rankin – who are also shortlisted for the Bloody Scotland Debut Prize, the latest book by Gavin Bell (who has previously written as Mason Cross and Alex Knight) and Philip Miller who appears on the McIlvanney shortlist for the first time.

It’s also a triumph for indie publishers with Viper (Profile) appearing twice and Polygon (Birlinn) ensuring that indies dominate the list of finalists.

Kirsty Nicholson, Head of Marketing at awards sponsor Glencairn Crystal, said:
“We’re thrilled to once again be part of the McIlvanney Prize and to celebrate the incredible talent at the heart of Scotland’s crime-writing community. This year’s finalists have delivered stories that intrigue, thrill and captivate, showcasing the imagination and originality that make this crime fiction prize so special. We’ll be raising a Glencairn Glass to every finalist as we look forward to discovering who takes home this year’s prize. Congratulations to all the shortlisted authors and the best of luck!”

The presentation of both prizes will take place in the Church of the Holy Rude at 5pm on Friday 18 September before a grand procession led by the two winners and guest programmer Denise Mina to her event with Lee Child at The Albert Halls.

Surface by Olivier Norek (translated by Nick Caistor)

Today I'm helping close the blog tour for Surface, written by Olivier Norek and translated from the French by Nick Caistor. It's a great book which I read in two days. Huge thanks to Zoe O'Farrell at Zooloo's Book Tours for inviting me to take part and to the publisher for my review copy.

 

The Blurb

Police capitaine Noémie Chastain has everything: a coveted position in Paris, a devoted team and a loving partner.

On a dawn raid in a grimy Parisian banlieue, in an instant, she loses it all. Shot by the drug dealer she was about to arrest, she is left with serious scars on her face and deeper, longer-lasting damage to her psyche.

Pushed out of her job in Paris by superiors concerned that her disfigurement would damage team morale, abandoned by her boyfriend, she is posted to a police department that serves six sparsely populated communes in the back of beyond, in the southern département of Aveyron. Her brief: to report back on the police department and give head office an excuse to close it altogether.

But when the body of a child floats to the surface of the man-made lake that hides the buried past of the village of Avalone, Capitaine Chastain is forced to take the opportunity to prove her worth and win back her job in Paris. To solve the case, she must lead a team more used to tracking down stolen combine harvesters – handsome Lieutenant Valant, the mayor’s son; ex-Drug Squad Brigadier Bousquet; and green local boy “Bambi” – through the twists and turns of what has become a murder investigation and uncover the dark secrets that have haunted the village for twenty years.

 

My Review

Last year I read The Winter Warriors by this author, and enjoyed it. That was historical fiction based on a true event. Surface is a very different book, set now, and I enjoyed it very much. 

As it mentions in the blurb, Noémie Chastain, a respected capitaine in the Paris Drug Squad, suffers a terrible injury to a large part of her face, which leaves terrible scars. People either stare at her or can't bear to look at her. And she loses part of who she is following the incident, feels lost and isolated, as her supervisor does his best to push her out of the way. To help her deal with the psychological effects of her injury she works with hospital psychiatrist Melchior, intially in person, later online. He looks at her normally, isn't repulsed, treats her just as he would any other patient. He's kind and gentle when he needs to be, straight talking at other times. I thought he was great. The same can not be said about Adriel. I was so disappointed in him and his behaviour, which I'm sure is the reaction the author wanted. 

Noémie is sent to the Aveyron region, which is in the countryside and nothing at all like Paris. And generally very quiet with regards to crime. She arrives angry and is initially abrasive to her new colleagues. But she is accepted, and her team treat her with respect. She doesn't want to be there, though, until a body is found, then she is in her element, feels more at ease because she knows what to do.

I loved Noémie. She is so strong and determined, not willing to let her injury and its effects define her. It was really interesting to watch her recovery, to a degree, and to see the changes in her as she begins to find herself again. The investigation itself is large and complex, going back twenty five years and opening some painful wounds. There is tension, and peril more than once for Noémie before the conclusion. And there is a sting in the tail too. 

I loved Surface. It felt fresh, and has a superb, damaged, gutsy heroine. It's well written (and well translated, thanks to Nick Caistor), populated with believable characters (Marguerite Saulnier was a stand out for me) and a cracking crime story. Just one thing - who do I complain to about the Hugo situation? Didn't turn our the way I wanted at all! 😂 Highly recommend this one. 

The Author

Olivier Norek spent 18 years in the French police force, where he rose to the rank of capitaine. Since he began to write crime fiction, his books have sold millions of copies and won many prizes. The Winter Warriors was his first historical novel and sold over 400,000 in France. Surface is his next book translated into English and has already won multiple awards in France and has been adapted into a hit TV series.

Bloody Scotland 2026 Influencers Tour

Bloody Scotland starts a fortnight today and I'm really delighted to be on the Influencers Tour again this year - many thanks to Fiona Brownlee, Tim Donald, Bob McDevitt and Dawn Geddes. Trouble is, I've been asked to pick just two events that I'm looking forward to this year - but there are so many fantastic interviews and panels taking place it's hard to pick!

So I've gone with the two events I am looking forward to the most. Unfortunately, I can only pick one of them to attend as they are on at exactly the same time! But they are both going to be fantastic and are both worth checking out. And the first one is also available as part of the digital pass.


Denise Mina presents SA Cosby
Saturday 19th September, 11:30am, The Albert Halls

What the brochure says:

We are delighted to welcome one of the most dynamic voices in crime fiction on his first visit to Stirling. Over the course of five exceptional novels, SA Cosby has firmly established himself as the genre’s rising star. With the breathtaking Blacktop Wasteland, and the unforgettable Razorblade Tears Shawn has racked up awards and acclaim in equal measure and achieved global success.

Shawn’s homeland is the American south which he again depicts brilliantly in his latest novel, the exhilarating King of Ashes. It is a gritty tale of family and secrets and is a powerful reminder that nothing lasts forever.

Shawn will be interviewed by Denise Mina.

What I can add:

I haven't yet read King of Ashes but I recently re-read Blacktop Wasteland and have just finished Razor Blade Tears, both to be reviewed here in due course. They were beautifully characterised novels both featuring ordinary guys who have left behind the 'life' but find themselves in (different) out of the ordinary circumstances and who make fateful decisions that will change their lives forever. Full of tension and jeopardy, each is heartbreaking in its own way. So I'm really looking forward to reading the other novels and hearing what Shawn has to say about his writing and beyond.

You can book tickets for this event here.

Across the Pond: Gavin Bell, Edel Coffey, Tariq Ashkanani
Saturday 19th September, 11:30am, Made in Stirling

What the brochure says:

We travel west with three outstanding writers whose books are set in what we used to call the good ol’ US of A.

A killer has committed four murders in four weeks in four American cities, all of living at 138 Main Street in Gavin Bell’s ingenious thriller. Corruption, murder and dangerous secrets amid Manhattan’s elite are rampant in the scintillating In Glass Houses by Edel Coffey. Tariq Ashkanani’s atmospheric The Hollow Boys is a dark slice of classic American gothic as a nine-year-old boy comes back from the dead.

This event will be chaired by Susie Green.

What I can add:

I love Gavin Bell's writing - he has previously written under the names Mason Cross and Alex Knight - and recently reviewed 138 Main Street here. I found it to be a complex, well thought out and beautifully written novel that fully satisfies. I haven't read any Edel Coffey yet but In Gllass Houses sounds great. Last but not least, I have read a couple of Tariq Ashkanani's books including The Hollow Boys - review to follow. I can tell you the man has a dark mind! The Hollow Boys starts dark and only gets darker! Brilliantly written, though.

This is sure to be another interesting discussion well worth checking out.

You can book tickets for this event here:

You can check out all the events, book tickets or purchase a digital pass at https://bloodyscotland.com/.